Onalaska-Law.com
  • HOME Page
  • OWI/DWI/DUI Defense
  • Car Accidents and Personal Injury
  • Criminal Charges
  • ACTUAL CRIMINAL & OWI/DWI RESULTS
  • Motorcycle Accidents
  • Attorney Info
  • Contact Us
  • Onalaska-Law Blog
  • Map of Location in Onalaska
  • Court Directory & Legal Resources

NOW IN WISCONSIN TOO, "IGNORANCE OF THE LAW IS NO EXCUSE" (UNLESS YOU'RE COP!).

7/15/2015

 
As we pointed out in an earlier article, one of the first principles learned by students of criminal law is "Ignorantia juris non excusat", or "Ignorance of the law is no excuse".  Otherwise, people could easily excuse their criminal actions by saying, "I thought that was legal."  The Supreme Court for the State of Wisconsin (a.k.a. "SCOW"), in State v. Houghton, has made a huge exception to that rule:  Ignorance of the law is an excuse, but only if you're a cop. 

It's official, as I expected, SCOW has adopted the dangerous precedent created by the Supreme Court of the United States ("SCOTUS") in Heien v. North Carolina, wherein the Court ruled that the police--the one group that definitely should know the law--can be excused for their ignorance of the law, so long as the ignorance was "reasonable".  

The ruling in State v. Houghton, filed just yesterday, overturned SCOW's earlier cases, State v. Longcore, 2000 WI 23, 233 Wis. 2d 278, 607 N.W.2d 620 and State v. Brown, 2014 WI 69, ¶22, 355 Wis. 2d 668, 850 N.W.2d 66, which firmly held that traffic stops cannot be based upon mistakes of law.  Brown was decided less than a year ago.  As Justice Abrahamson decries in her dissent, "What happened to precedent and  stare decisis?" (Let the decision stand.) 

In Houghton, the officer pulled a car over under the mistaken belief that having no front license plate and having object (a pine tree air freshener and a small GPS unit) in the windshield of a car violates Wis. Stat. s. 346.88(3)(b).  In fact, the State conceded the officer was mistaken about the legality of no front license plate, and the referenced statute only prohibits such objects that "obstruct[] the driver's clear view through the front windshield."  The Court of Appeals ruled that these objects did not give the officer--who later found a bunch of MJ and other evidence as a result of the stop--probable cause to stop the vehicle.  However, SCOW said, using Heien, that the officer's ignorance of the law was close enough and would not make the traffic stop unconstitutional.  

"Why should we care?", you might ask.  As Justice Jackson of SCOTUS once pointed out, the police are "engaged in the often competitive enterprise of ferreting out crime."  Finding drugs and making busts scores them job and ego points.  We do not want to create incentives whereby being able to convincingly feign ignorance will advance your career.  

The Fourth Amendment is the only thing that prevents the police from stopping us at any time, at any place, for any reason.  We are supposed to live in a free society where we get left alone unless we are doing something wrong.  Allowing the police to stop cars on a mere pretext--such as a perfectly-legal air freshener dangling from the rear-view mirror--will definitely turn up more illegal drugs, but it also robs of our freedom.   I'd rather we be honest about it and legalize road blocks. 

SCOW had the opportunity to interpret the Wisconsin Constitution to reject the premise that the police are held to a lower standard than the citizens of Wisconsin.  Instead, it chose to go along with SCOTUS and create more authority for pretextual stops.  That sucks.

PRACTICE POINTER:  When you bring your motion for suppression, subpoena the officer's training materials so that you can demonstrate that he/she knew what the law actually is.

IS JUDGE RAMONA GONZALEZ REALLY THAT BAD?

7/1/2015

 
A story in the La Crosse Tribune describes Judge Ramona Gonzalez's role in getting a defendant's car back to his house after telling him in court, apparently during a bond hearing, that he "will have to figure out someplace else to keep his vehicle other than his house".  This, according to the case notes on CCAP.   Apparently, these remarks made their way into the bond as a condition, because the police thought Rose was ordered not to have the vehicle at his home.  Sometime later, the Judge personally spoke with Mr. Rose, and she arranged for her own husband to drive Rose's vehicle--the same vehicle Rose reportedly illegally drove to court and had been using to "terrorize" his neighbors and endanger the community--back to Rose's residence.     

La Crosse Chief of Police, Rob Abraham is apparently not pleased.  He was quoted in the article--which quote appears three times, twice blown up (not that the La Crosse Tribune is ever guilty of ginning up controversy between the judges and police).   The Chief saw this as a reason to "question the impartiality of the judicial system". 

To begin, if the Judge's courtroom comments are correctly reported on CCAP, then her statement about "figur[ing] out someplace else to keep his vehicle" does not appear to be an order, but more advisory in nature.  The fact that she later amended the bond for clarification does not change that.  Second, in my opinion, the Chief's comments, the article as a whole--and the typical uniformed, silly comments that accompany it--unfairly portray the Judge as chummy with criminals, and against the police.  I think this misses the "big picture." 

Mr. Rose is 18 years old.  The article alludes to the fact that he has been involved with the courts as a juvenile.  Judge Gonzalez pointed out that he has "no family support".  My bet is that Judge Gonzalez has some experience with Mr. Rose, and that she knows him better than most.  My experience is that Judge Gonzalez is the kind of Judge that tries to reach people and change their behavior.  She understands that simply locking people up and taking their property is a formula proven not to work.  By her other comments, it is clear that Mr. Rose's behavior troubled the Judge.  But helping Mr. Rose save his car from the police impound does not make her an aider and abettor.  She ordered Mr. Rose not to drive the vehicle.   
The article also explains that Judge Gonzalez not only helped Rose with his car, she later checked back in on him to be sure he was okay and had food at his house.   


What kind of judge do we want for La Crosse County?:  One who locks people up and then waits for their return on another crime (and looks good in the press), or a judge who makes sure that one out of hundreds that come before her has something to eat?  Give her a break!
  

  





      



Minneapolis 'Pedal Pub' Haters Alert: Water Balloons & Squirt Guns Lead to Forceful Arrests by Squirted Off-Duty Police.

5/28/2015

 
I think this one speaks for itself: CLICK HERE.  

The Wisconsin Remedy When "Potentially-Exculpatory" Evidence is Destroyed?  Nothing.

5/11/2015

 
Imagine that you are involved in a serious traffic accident.  Your blood is drawn as part of the investigation, even though there is no evidence you were impaired. Complicated blood tests--tests done at a very busy State lab, and performed more than 7 months after the fact--come back showing evidence of THC.  You are charged with a felony.  You deny smoking marijuana.  You want to prove the test was wrong through an independent test.  However, you can't because the lab that tested your blood destroyed the remaining blood as part of its policy.  What is your remedy under the law?  The Supreme Court for Wisconsin and the US Supreme Court both say, essentially, "nothing".  That was the facts and holding of State v. Weissinger, the companion case to State v. Luedtke, which were recently handed down by the Supreme Court for Wisconsin.  

The US Supreme Court case, Youngblood v. Arizona, 488 U.S. 51 (1988), controls in situations where "potentially-exculpatory" evidence is been destroyed. The case has been excoriated by legal scholars.  The case will continue to control in Wisconsin.


Youngblood says that evidence can be suppressed from trial if a defendant is deprived of the ability to test it because it has been destroyed.  However, in order for a court to suppress, the defendant must prove that the destroyed evidence was (1) "potentially-exculpatory" and, (2) destroyed in "bad faith".  


Two problems: (1) It is nearly impossible to show that evidence was destroyed in "bad faith" (with "malice" or the actual intent to deprive the defendant of exculpatory evidence); and (2) it is nearly impossible to show that evidence is more than "potentially-exculpatory" after it has been destroyed.  I'm sure no one knows that more than Ms. Weissinger.

The Supreme Court for Wisconsin has the authority to interpret the Wisconsin Constitution so that it provides more protection than the flawed Youngblood case allows.  However, the court refused  to do so in Luedtke and Weissinger.  Instead, it stood behind that good old judicial maxim "stare decisis" (let the decision stand).  Therefore, because these defendants could not prove the blood was more than "potentially-exculpatory" (because it was destroyed), and could not show "bad faith", the only test result that will go to the jury is the one the state lab produced.  And there's your "due process under the a law."     



  

         "We're right by the Y."   Just a Short Swim North of "Sunny" Sunfish

4/24/2015

 
Picture

"IGNORANCE OF THE LAW IS NO EXCUSE" (Unless You're a Cop).

12/16/2014

 
  "Heien gives the police more leeway to stop cars for the wrong reason, and that SUCKS." 
One of the first principles learned by students of criminal law is "Ignorantia juris non excusat", or "Ignorance of the law is no excuse".  That makes sense, doesn't it?  Otherwise, people could excuse their criminal actions by saying, "I thought that was legal."  However, yesterday the Supreme Court of the United States ("SCOTUS") ruled that the police--the one group that definitely should know the law--can be excused for their ignorance of the law, so long as the ignorance was "reasonable".

So what is a mistake of law, you ask?  For example, if a police officer pulled someone over because he/she thought the person's windshield was cracked, and it was not cracked, that's a mistake of fact.  If, however, he/she made the stop because of a cracked windshield, and cracked windshields are not even illegal, that's a mistake of law.   

HEIEN v. NORTH CAROLINA is the case, handed down just yesterday.  Heien gives the police more leeway to stop cars for the wrong reason, and that SUCKS.  In Heien, a police officer stopped a vehicle under the mistaken belief that having only one brake light was illegal in North Carolina.  It wasn't illegal.  This was a mistake Chief Justice Roberts found "objectively reasonable".  Cocaine was later found in the vehicle. The North Carolina Supreme Court reversed a lower appellate court, which ruled that the cocaine had to be suppressed because there was no grounds for the stop.  SCOTUS AFFIRMED. 

The holding in Heien states that, at least under the US Constitution, both mistakes of fact and mistakes of law are now excusable so long as they are reasonable mistakes, and suppression of evidence will not be required when a such mistake is made.  I call this tantamount to a "good-faith exception" for traffic stops.

Prior to this ruling, reasonable mistakes of fact by police were generally excusable, but reasonable mistakes of law were not.  In Wisconsin, that has been the law for over 15 years.   State vs. Longcore, 226 Wis. 2d 1, 594 N.W.2d 412 (Ct. App. 1999).  That principle was recently reiterated in State v. Brown, 2014 WI 269.  Therefore, if the police made a stop on a mistake of law and discover evidence as a consequence, that evidence must be suppressed, even if the mistake was reasonable.  

Heien does not necessarily mean that reasonable mistakes of law are now excusable in Wisconsin.  The Wisconsin court can interpret  the Wisconsin constitution in a way that is more generous to citizens' rights than the US Constitution has been interpreted by SCOTUS.  However, the Wisconsin court has generally followed the interpretations of SCOTUS on issues of Fourth Amendment law when deciding the scope of Article I, section 11, Wisconsin's counterpart to the Fourth Amendment.  Therefore, the decision does not bode good things for Longcore and Brown.  

POLICE "BODY CAMERAS" CAN'T HELP IF THEY ARE TURNED OFF

12/3/2014

 
The following is my letter to the editor of the La Crosse Tribune, submitted today:

Police "Body Cameras" Can't Help If They Are Turned Off.

In the wake of the situation in Ferguson, MO, President Obama has pledged $75 Million in federal funds, specifically to equip police officers with digital "body cameras".  The idea, of course, is that these cameras will objectively capture encounters between police and citizens.  This will take the "he said, she said" element out of the equation.  It will eliminate the human elements that have led to infamously unreliable eyewitness accounts.  It will protect the police from false accusations.  It will keep police "more honest".  All of this may be true, so long as the cameras are actually working and on, and if the footage is properly preserved.         

I am a criminal defense and car accident attorney.  As such, I have over the last 15 years routinely requested and examined police audio-video evidence.  Advances in digital technology have led to nearly every police vehicle, and nearly every police interview room, being equipped with audio-video equipment.  I want the audio-video record for obvious reasons:  It is often the best evidence of what actually happened, and of what actually was said.  It can be the best or worst evidence for a client; but it is the truth that matters most. 

In the case of most police squad cars, the digital equipment is designed to be perpetually on.  The system is designed to preserve the audio and/or video record anytime an officer activates emergency lights or sirens, or manually starts recording.  In either case, the equipment will also capture a period of time before the equipment was activated.  Importantly, officers are equipped with wireless microphones on their persons, which often allows them to record witness statements.  

Most law enforcement agencies have in place orders dictating how the audio and/or video equipment is to be used and maintained.  These orders usually require officers to inspect the equipment at the outset of their shift, to ensure it is properly functioning.  These orders also require that officers actually use the equipment to preserve evidence, allowing few exceptions.  

Despite these orders, there is, in my opinion, a shocking percentage of cases where video and/or audio-recorded squad evidence is not being properly captured and/or is not being properly preserved.  I have seen many cases of field sobriety tests done out of view of the camera.  I have seen many cases where officers' microphones are turned off; selectively turned off and on; or not functioning at all, while reportedly incriminating statements are being made.  I have seen multiple cases of audio-video not being recorded because the digital storage device was "full" or the equipment was down.  I have seen many cases where there is no video, no audio, and no explanation at all.  This very morning, I received a letter from the Town of Campbell Police Department, in response to my request, saying only, "[D]ue to computer issues we are unable to retrieve any audio/video recordings of this incident."       

I don't like to be critical of the police; but it is part of my job description.  I am also a citizen, and I rely on the police, just like everyone else.  Police are human.  They also have tough jobs.  Mistakes will happen.  That having been said, if it is true that "the conqueror gets to write history", then this technology must not only be available to the police, it must be properly used by them.  We cannot tolerate the selective or sloppy use of police cameras.                     

Chris Dyer, Attorney and Counselor at Law, Onalaska, WI.        

SCOW Will Decide Whether Statute that Punishes Having  'Any Detectable Amount of a Restricted Controlled Substance' in Blood While Driving is Unconstitutional.  

10/21/2014

 
The Supreme Court for the State of Wisconsin has granted a Petition for Review of State v. Michael R. Luedtke, 2013AP1737-CR.  Luedtke failed to persuade  the Court of Appeals that punishing a person simply for having any amount of a restricted controlled substance in their blood while driving violates the driver's right to due process of the law.  


The statue at issues is Wis. Stat.  s. 346.63(1)(am).  The substance most often detected is Delta 9 THC, the active component of THC.  Other states, including Minnesota, exclude THC from the list of restricted substances.


According to the Court of Appeals, the statute does not violate due process even though it does not require the driver to (1) actually be impaired; or (2) knowingly or intentionally ingest THC/restricted substances.  Statutes that require "knowledge" or "intent" are said to have a "scienter" element.  Those that do not, like section 346.63(1)(am) are called "strict liability" offenses.   The Court of Appeals decision can be summarized as follows, "[B]ecause no reliable measure of impairment exists for many illicit drugs, the legislature reasonably could conclude that the more prudent course was to ban any amount in the driver’s system." 


In a previous blog, I gave my reasons why section 346.63(1)(am) leads to police abuse.  It is my sincere hope that the Supreme Court will see things differently than the Court of Appeals.  However, I am not holding my breath.

VICTIM ADVOCACY GONE MAD: PROSECUTORS RIGHTFULLY SUED BY WRONGFULLY-ACCUSED PARENTS

10/7/2014

 
Thal and Julian Wendrow sued Michigan Prosecutor David Gorcyca, his former chief assistant, Deborah Carley,  and Andrea Dean, a former judicial candidate now in private practice.   The Wendrows are the parents of a severely-autistic 14 year-old mute child.  In 2007, the child reportedly typed a note to a teacher's assistant stating she had been raped by her father since early childhood.  However, the  teacher's guide "aided" the child's, using a method of typing called facilitated communication, which is widely debunked.  The police even interrogated the child's younger brother, lying to him, saying they had a video of the father raping the child.  On the basis of this unbelievably unreliable information, the police and prosecutors ran with it, arrested and jailed the Wendrows (Mr. Wendrow for 80 days), putting their children into protective custody. 

According to the USA Today, the suit was filed in 2008.  Since then, the West Bloomfield Police Department settled for  $1.8 million, the state settled at $850,000 and Walled Lake Schools will pay the family $1.1 million.  I guess that fills the war chest in terms of pursuing these prosecutors.

I have represented a number of people charged with sexual assault of a child in La Crosse County.  These are difficult and complicated cases.  None of those cases resulted a trial, let alone a conviction.  I am also a parent of young children.  As such, I appreciate the most zealous of advocacy when upholding the rights of child victims.  However, charges of this nature are extremely destructive.  Cases are far too often brought with evidence, and under circumstances, which  are very untrustworthy.  Even the best of intentions--when not guided by common sense--will leave ruined lives in the wake.  This witch hunt is obviously one such case.     

MJ USER ALERT: USE OF MJ 9 HOURS (and maybe 24 hours) BEFORE DRIVING IS GROUNDS FOR ARREST AND FORCED BLOOD DRAW TO SCREEN FOR ANY DRUG.

8/15/2014

 
  "The most persuasive evidence known to the officer was Hubbard’s own admission that he smoked marijuana (“weed”) within nine hours of driving. The officer’s training instructed that this would be recent enough for marijuana to be detected in his blood." 
Wisconsin drivers are reminded that in Wisconsin, as opposed to MN for example, just having any "detectable amount 
of a restricted controlled substance" in their blood IS an OWI.   Wis. Stat.  s. 346.63(1)(am) (emphasis added).  Delta 9 THC, the active component of marijuana, is a "restricted controlled substance."  Wis. Stat. s. 340.01(50m).  That means that a driver does not have to be impaired by marijuana--or anything else--to be arrested for OWI.  The arresting officer only has to show "probable cause" that the driver's blood may have a "detectable amount of a restricted controlled substance" present.   Once the blood is drawn--forcibly if necessary--whatever restricted controlled substance is found by the lab "screening" the blood can (and likely will) result in an OWI charge under s. 346.63(1)(am). 

The point is being made again, this time in an unpublished Wisconsin Court of Appeals opinion released Wednesday,
 STATE OF WISCONSIN V. KENT W. HUBBARD.  Hubbard was stopped for a bad tail light at 2:45 a.m. (of course).  He reportedly had bloodshot eyes and admitted drinking two shots.  He also admitted that he smoked marijuana that day, nine hours before.  His PBT (preliminary breath test) registered a BAC of only .02.  He reportedly consented to a search of his vehicle, which produced "two glass pipes containing burnt residue as well as a pill bottle containing a green seed and a Ziploc bag containing a green leafy substance, both smelling like marijuana".  

Hubbard was arrested for suspicion of driving with a detectable amount of a restricted controlled substance.  He refused a blood draw.  His blood was taken anyway.  The decision does not state exactly what was disclosed by the screening tests, but the only thing referenced is methamphetamine.  That's right--not THC, not ethanol (alcohol)--but meth.  

Hubbard was charged with one count of operating a motor vehicle while under the influence of an intoxicant, controlled substance, or any other drug or combination of substances, contrary to Wis. Stat. s. 346.63(1)(a), and one count of operating a motor vehicle with a detectable amount of a restricted controlled substance in his blood, contrary to s. 346.63(1)(am).  The "detectable amount of a restricted controlled substance", here meth, had nothing to do with the facts giving rise to his investigation or arrest.  However, the test result, showing meth present, was presumably the reason Hubbard ended up pleading to OWI under s. 346.63(1)(a). 

Hubbard challenged his arrest.   At the hearing, the arresting officer testified that "he had received drug training related to impaired driving, where he had learned that marijuana could remain in the bloodstream for '24 hours or longer.'”  (emphasis added.)

The courts ruled that the officer had probable cause to arrest for suspicion of driving with a restricted controlled substance under s. 346.63(1)(am).  In finding probable cause, the Court of Appeals stated, "The most persuasive evidence known to the officer was Hubbard’s own admission that he smoked marijuana (“weed”) within nine hours of driving.  The officer’s training instructed that this would be recent enough for marijuana to be detected in his blood." 

Many believe that s. 346.63(1)(am) promotes a "witch hunt" because it does not even require evidence of impairment, only evidence to believe the person may have some restricted controlled substance in his/her blood.  This decision suggests that an admission of recent marijuana use (if you call 9, let alone 24, hours "recent") could be grounds to arrest, draw blood, and then have the Wisconsin State Lab of Hygiene or Wisconsin Crime Lab go on  a fishing expedition for any "restricted controlled substances" by the process of Mass Spectrometry Gas Chromatography.  If any such substances are found--even if they have nothing to do with the reason for the stop or arrest--the driver can be guilty under s. 346.63(1)(am).  

What's further troubling is that the Wisconsin State Lab of Hygiene, the lab largely responsible for testing for ethanol and restricted controlled substance testing, has clearly been strained by the volume of cases coming to its lab.  So much that in 2011-12 it was forced to contract out 600 cases for mass spectrometry testing to a 'for profit' lab in PA.  How do I know?  I am still fighting one of the cases sent to PA for testing.  There does not have to be cause to believe the blood contains any other substance, but the testing can find and identify most any drug.

 OWI convictions are big-ticket cases for patrol officers.  In La Crosse, WI, a patrol officer might even find themselves highlighted in the La Crosse Tribune for having the most OWI arrests.  Why is that a bad thing, you might ask?  In most cases it isn't.  Nobody wants an impaired driver on the road.  However, I have had cases that start with a stop for something like a tail light, then moved to an investigation for drunk driving because the driver admitted some amount of drinking.   After humiliating field tests, the PBT shows under .08 BAC.  Then the question follows: "Have you had anything else?"  If the person admits to smoking pot any time recently, then we're off to the land of bloodshot eyes, yellow tongues, fevers and pupil size to justify the arrest.  


Like Hubbard,  arrest for THC can end up with charges for some other substance, whether it be meth, metabolites of cocaine, or whatever.  This can happen even though the "symptoms" between using pot or some other substance may be completely different.   It doesn't take a hippy to think this does resemble a bit of a 'witch hunt'.  
<<Previous
Forward>>

    Author

    Christopher W. Dyer, a Wisconsin and Minnesota Trial Lawyer, serving La Crosse and surrounding counties.

    Archives

    January 2018
    December 2016
    October 2016
    August 2016
    June 2016
    February 2016
    December 2015
    October 2015
    July 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    December 2014
    October 2014
    August 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013

    Categories

    All
    Blood Testing
    Breath Testing
    Car Accidents
    Domestic Charges
    Forfeiture Cases
    Going To Court
    How To Choose A Good Lawyer
    Implied Consent
    In The News
    Minnesota Dwi
    Owi 1st
    Repeat Owi
    Traffic Court
    Urine Testing.

    RSS Feed